Most of the
Afghan war against the Soviet Union was fought by Mujahideen
and Pakistani soldiers using Israeli arms supplied after General
Zia ul Haq entered into secret deals with the Israelis, a
book published here has revealed.
The revelation, coming at a
time when the Pakistani Army Chief is campaigning for recognition
of Israel, throws hitherto concealed light on secret Army-Israeli
deals and their cooperation through the CIA. It reveals that
the Army was not averse to secret defence cooperation, although
publicly it did not acknowledge any contact with the Israelis.
Congressman Charles Wilson
from Texas, a great pro-Pakistan activist who hated the Indians,
was the central figure to get these CIA-funded weapons for
Pakistan and is credited in the book as the man who broke
up the Soviet Union with the help of a 48-year old Houston
woman with whom General Zia ul Haq also had an affair.
The book, “Charlie Wilson's
War: The Extraordinary Story of the Largest Covert Operation
in History” is written by journalist George Crile, who
was an editor at Harper's in the Seventies and who is now
a producer at 60 Minutes II.
The 550-page book has been
a best seller in US but so far it has not attracted any attention
in Pakistan or South Asia. “I don’t know why it
is so but I have not yet received any reaction from Pakistan,”
Charlie Wilson, now a senior lobbyist for Pakistan in Washington,
told South Asia Tribune on July 17, 2003.
Analysts think the present
military regime would not like the book to become popular
in Pakistan as it reveals a lot of their secrets, including
Army's deals with Israel.
Asked what he thought now that
a major debate had been initiated by President Musharraf on
whether Pakistan should recognize Israel, keeping in view
his disclosures that Pakistan and Israel were defence partners
years ago, Charlie Wislon refrained from offering any comment.
"I will not comment on
the present situation," he told me on July 17, saying:
"It is for the governments of the two countries to decide
what they want to do."
Wilson, who admits in the book
that his power in the House of Representatives had come primarily
“as a result of his work with the Israeli lobby”
told me in an interview basically there could never be a 100
per cent agreement between the subject and an author, but
“I have not protested on anything that has been written
in Crile’s book.” He was asked whether there was
anything inaccurate in the book about the Pak-Israeli and
other deals.
The book reveals that Wilson
made the proposal to General Zia to deal with the Israelis
during Zia’s first visit to US after the Soviet invasion
of Afghanistan. The proposal was made grand dinner hosted
by the Houston lady, Joanne Herring, who was named later as
Honorary Consul of Pakistan and became a critical player in
the war.
“American liberals and
human-rights advocates would never change their view of Zia
as a Third World thug, but his American visit was something
of a triumph, and Joanne’s dinner was part of the reason
it succeeded,” the book says.
Joanne Herring later became
Zia’s sweetheart and Charlie Wilson is quoted in the
book saying: “ He (Zia) was so spell bound by Herring,
and took her so seriously, that to the utter dismay of his
entire foreign office, he made her Pakistan roving ambassador
to the world and even awarded her his country’s highest
honor, the title of Quaid-e-Azam.
Says Wilson: “Zia would
leave cabinet meetings just to take Joanne’s calls.
There was no affair with Zia but it’s impossible to
deal with Joanne and not deal with her on a sexual basis.
No matter who you are, you take those phone calls.”
These words of Charlie say a lot more about Zia-Joanne relationship
as Charlie himself had a long and deep one.
When asked by SA Tribune on
July 17 whether Joanne was alive and was he still in contact
with her, Charlie said he had not talked to her for the last
10 years but he knew she was alive and in Houston.
It was thus Joanne’s
dinner in Houston which launched Zia in US and started the
Pak-Israeli cooperation in arms. The book says of that event:
“Zia had dangerous decisions to make in the coming months
about the CIA’s involvement in his inflamed North-West
Frontier, and all of them centered on whether he could trust
the United States. Joanne’s startling toast was strangely
therapeutic for the much-maligned leader, who remembered how
quickly Jimmy Carter had turned on him. In Houston that night,
Joanne Herring saw to it that a host of powerful Americans
actually honored him. And that same night, Charlie Wilson
provided yet another dimension to Zia’s growing partnership
with the United States when he took the general into a side
room for a private talk. The congressman had a novel proposition
for – the Muslim dictator. Would Zia be willing to deal
with the Israelis?” (P-131).
“This was not the sort
of proposal just anyone could have made. But by now, the Pakistanis
believed that Charlie Wilson had been decisive in getting
them the disputed F-16 radar systems. As he saw it, Wilson
had pulled off the impossible. Now the congressman, in his
tuxedo, began to take Zia into the forbidden world where the
Israelis were prepared to make deals no one need hear about.”
“He told Zia about his
experience the previous year when the Israelis had shown him
the vast stores of Soviet weapons they had captured from the
PLO in Lebanon. The weapons were perfect for the mujahideen,
he told Zia. If Wilson could convince the CIA to buy them,
would Zia have any problems passing them on to the Afghans?
Zia, ever the pragmatist, smiled on the proposal, adding,
“Just don’t put any Stars of David on the boxes.”
“With that encouragement,
Wilson pushed on. Just the previous month, he had learned
that the Israelis were secretly upgrading the Chinese army’s
Russian-designed T-55 tanks. In Islamabad, he had been startled
to see that the Chinese were supplying Pakistan with T-55s.
The congressman now proposed that Zia enter into a similar
secret arrangement with the Israelis. “I was trying
to rig it for Israel to do the upgrade without the Chinese
operating as the middlemen,” Wilson explained in the
book.
“It was no simple proposition.
Three years earlier, a mere rumor that Israel had been involved
in an attack on the Great Mosque in Mecca had so radicalized
the Pakistani Muslim population that thousands had stormed
the U.S. embassy in Pakistan and burned it to the ground.
Zia was mindful of his people’s hatred for both Israel
and the United States, and he might have been expected to
nip this in the bud. Instead, he encouraged Wilson to continue.
“The congressman was
acutely aware of the minefield he was walking through. Publicly,
Pakistan and Israel would have to remain foes, he conceded.
But as Zia well understood, Pakistan and Israel shared the
same deadly foe in the Soviet Union. And the fact was that
each could profit mightily by secretly cooperating with the
other. If Zia would follow the lead of the Chinese, Wilson
said, he could increase the striking power of his tanks, and
there might be other areas of military and technological cooperation
where both countries could mutually profit.
“Pakistan did not have
diplomatic relations with Israel, and Wilson certainly had
no authority to serve as a quasi secretary of state. In fact,
with this kind of talk, the congressman was walking dangerously
close to violating the Logan Act, which prohibits anyone other
than the president or his representatives from conducting
foreign policy. But as the two rejoined Joanne’s party,
Zia left the congressman with an understanding that he was
authorized to begin secret negotiations to open back channels
between Islamabad and Jerusalem. Wilson would leave for Israel
in March and travel on to Pakistan to brief Zia immediately
afterward.”
Wilson then began a series
of visits to Israel, taking along beautiful women, one of
them a belle dancer, who actually performed in front of the
Egyptian Defense Minister during one of the visits. She was
also with Wilson on a trip to Pakistan and at many places
she was described as Mrs. Wilson to satisfy the Muslim sensitivities.
The book describes one such
visit in which a lady, Carol, was with Wilson. “When
they landed in Israel...Carol was thrilled to be in the land
of the Bible. Wilson would disappear with Zvi (an official)
every morning, sending her off in the embassy’s chauffeur-driven
Mercedes to see the holy sights. One afternoon, he came back
“acting like a kid in a candy store,” she said.
She didn’t completely understand what he was talking
about, but she remembers that it had to do with T-55 tanks
and secret deals with Pakistan.
“I’ve never breathed
a word about this before,” she recalled. “And
Charlie only gave me bits and pieces, but he was so excited
because he thought he was going to be able to do something
that no one else could. Charlie is a giver, and here he was
saving the world.” What Wilson was doing during the
day in Israel was scheming with Zvi’s associates at
IMI, the weapons conglomerate that produces the country’s
artillery, tank shells, and machine guns. It has the second
biggest payroll in Israel and is inextricably entwined with
the military and security apparatus of the Jewish state.
“Wilson’s scheming
was conducted not merely out of Carol’s sight but outside
that of the U.S. embassy, which ordinarily monitors congressional
activities abroad. One of the reasons for shadowing visiting
members of Congress is to discourage them from engaging in
negotiations that could place U.S. interests at risk. Wilson,
however, never shied away from negotiating, in effect, on
behalf of his government, and on this occasion he and his
Israeli friends had a wide range of business to transact…
“They turned next to
the T-55 upgrade proposal and to what their congressional
friend could offer President Zia, on behalf of Israel, when
he met with him in Pakistan at the end of the week. The Israelis
were hoping this deal would serve as the beginning of a range
of under-the-table understandings with Pakistan that the congressman
would continue to quietly negotiate for them.”
“But such was the stature
of this old congressional patron of Israel that the IMI chief
immediately set his weapons experts to work. By the time Wilson
was ready to leave, they’d presented him with an impressive-looking
design, complete with detailed specifications. It was a mule-portable,
multi-rocketed device named, to the congressman’s delight,
the Charlie Horse.”
Wilson cut the Pak-Israel deal
even without CIA knowledge. The book reveals that the CIA
man in Islamabad, Howard Hart, when asked years later, if
he knew about Wilson’s efforts to bring the Israelis
into the Afghan war, he dismissed this story out of hand,
insisting that the Pakistanis would never have permitted it.
“I would have burst into
hysterical laughter and locked myself in the bathroom before
proposing such a thing,” he said. “It was bad
enough for Zia to be dealing with the Americans, even secretly.
But the Israelis were so beyond the pale that it would have
been impossible. You have to understand that the Pakistanis
were counting on maintaining the image of holding the high
moral ground—of a religious brother helping a religious
brother. . . . It’s beyond comprehension to have tried
to bring the Israelis into it.”
“Yet right under Hart’s
nose,” the book says, “Wilson had proposed just
such an arrangement, and Zia and his high command had signed
on to implement it. Seven years later, Hart still knew nothing
about it.” (P-149).
The congressman began showed
Zia the design for the Charlie Horse and describing the Israelis’
T-55 proposal at a dinner in Rawalpindi. After establishing
what Zia wanted him to convey back to the Israelis, Wilson
came right to point they both wanted the same thing—to
expand the Afghan war— and Charlie had a plan to make
it possible.
Charlie Wilson himself ended
up overseeing much of this eccentric weapons program for Pakistan
out of his own congressional office, and it turned out to
be a wild and remarkable success story. “There were
all these little scientists in the Pentagon—bureaucratic
misfits who just needed to be freed,” Wilson recalled
years later. “We gave them a little money and made them
immune to procurement laws. They’re mad-scientist types.
They love to tinker with things that blow up but hate to fill
out forms. Hate to follow the chain of command. Hate to wait.”
“Within weeks, they began
developing an astonishing collection of weapons. The Spanish
mortar, for example, was designed to make it possible for
the mujahideen to communicate directly with American navigation
satellites to deliver repeated rounds within inches of their
designated targets. Global-positioning technology is well
known today, but back in 1985 it struck Wilson as the most
astonishing capability. Just the thought of Afghan tribesmen
who had never seen a flush toilet signaling an American satellite
to fire precision rounds at a Red Army stronghold was almost
too much to believe.
“The weapon’s name
was purposefully misleading, chosen to conceal the fact that
major portions of this “Spanish mortar” were being
built by the Israelis. Milt Bearden, the station chief who
would dominate the war’s later years, actually came
to rely on the steady stream of crazy new weapons that kept
coming on-line from this offbeat program. His strategy called
for introducing a new weapon into the battle every three months
or so, in order to bluff the Red Army into thinking their
enemy was better armed and supported than it was.
“The Spanish mortar,
for example, with its satellite-guided charge, was rarely
deployed and may only have succeeded because the Pakistani
ISI advisers were along to direct the fire. But the Soviets
didn’t know that. When the weapon was first used it
wiped out an entire Spetsnaz outpost with a volley of perfect
strikes. And as soon as Bearden learned from the CIA’s
intercepts that the commander of the 40th Army had helicoptered
to the scene, he knew that from that day on, the Soviets would
have to factor in the possibility that the mujahideen had
acquired some deadly targeting capability.
“For that reason alone,
the weapon was a success even if never fired again. Bearden
became so intoxicated with this kind of psychological warfare
that he later developed plans to have a group of mujahideen
shoot dead Russian soldiers with crossbows. To him, the vision
of men who might kill you with a bow and arrow one day or
with a satellite-guided mortar the next would be unnerving
to any army.” (P-393).
When the first Soviet helicopter
was downed by the Mujahideen with Israeli weapons, Charlie
Wilson was sent a special souvenir. “Charlie was the
first to be taken to see this temple of Soviet doom. There
Bearden (CIA Chief in Islamabad) had assembled a delegation
of 1SI officers and mujahideen. With great solemnity, the
station chief on behalf of the CIA, the ISI, and the Afghan
freedom fighters, presented Charlie with the spent gripstock
from the Stinger that Engineer Ghaffar had used to bring down
the first Hind.” (P-475).
|